Every time someone says, “I think it’s okay to love Jesus and not go to church,” I get a horrible feeling in my stomach. In fact, I get a little heated and confrontational.
I have had many conversations with young guys over the last several months about why they hate the church. Many of them are not Christians, albeit many of them are and many of them run in my circles. It is a common idea for young people today to think they can dig Jesus but not his church. They love “the Lord,” but have no idea what the message of the Bible is. Young people all over the country on college campuses spend Sunday mornings in their dorm room asleep or on someone’s floor hung over and have no desire whatsoever to be in a ‘church building.’
In retrospect, why is this sad and heretical statement so often repeated over and over again by young people all over the world?
Here’s what I think and what many have told me:
- Many who say this are non-regenerate. Many people who say, “You can love Jesus and not his church” really have no concept of what true Christianity is and are in fact non-regenerate. I realize this is a big statement. I’m not saying ‘all,’ though I am saying ‘many.’ Many have not been discipled as they should have been for whatever reason and have HUGE misunderstandings of what the church is; many have been influenced by guys they should stay away from (i.e., Brian McLaren, Tony Jones, Rob Bell)… anyone who labels themselves ‘Emergent.’ (I do realize that labeling Rob Bell as ‘bad’ just lost us 90% of our readers and got the other 10% really mad at me but that’s okay and a risk I’m willing to take); and many have been influenced by culture and are in fact more inclined to please others and have others like them than be obedient to Jesus.
- Hypocrisy. Young people can see right through hypocrisy. When you walk into most church buildings you see a lot of people who act like they have it all together yet they are dying inside for whatever reason. This is a big reason why young people hate the church… and why the world hates the church for that matter.
- Contemporary contemporariness. Everything is contemporary or tries to be contemporary! I’ve heard it said many times that , “Many churches look like a show.” When young people walk into churches they hear messages about not conforming to culture yet they are using culture to tell them that message. We must ask what does that look like and what does that mean? Many times when ‘lost’ people come into our churches they feel as though they were tricked into coming by a certain promotion or give away item.
- They are treated as a program. Let’s not be mistaken, our churches are very very very program driven. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it can be a very bad thing. I, myself, am very fond of programs when they are used properly and have been in many churches that use them well, but many churches see their task in reaching young people as very programmatic. Young people do not want to see themselves as a program. They want to be apart of the church community… not separate.
- Exclusivity. In this age it is not common for someone to hate you for thinking you are ‘right.’ People say all the time that ‘what is right for you is right only for you and what is right someone else is right only for them.’ Young people hate the fact that conservative Bible-believing Christians label the Bible as the ‘only’ way to know God. We are not teaching why truth is objective and why this is in fact true. It is interesting because Christians are attacked as being the only wrong ones for believing this when every one else is in the right. Young people do not want to come into churches and hear a 3 point message about you name it when they are first of all battling the issue of exclusivity.
Here’s’ the deal: We are not reaching and discipling as we ought. There are millions of lost college students all over the world who are in need of the gospel. They hate the church first of all because they are at odds with truth and are influenced by the principalities of this world. Young people are being influenced by college professors and the like to believe that truth is relative and anything that can be defined as the metaphysical world should be discarded behind the scientific method. Churches are not reaching young people where they are at… in their unbelief of truth, denial of truth, and relative and plural way of thinking and living. They can see through hypocrisy and programs. How should we reach them? Am I right or wrong? What do you think?
NOTE: I know many churches who reach young people and many young people who love Jesus and his church. This is not a universal blast.







March 25, 2010 at 11:20 am
Greg, I love this. I totally agree. Especially about Rob Bell and the other emergent church leaders. They give only one side of Christianity (the hope and the Loving God). They don’t speak of our sinfulness.
March 25, 2010 at 11:43 am
It’s crazy that so many young people flock to guys like Rob Bell without using discernment about what he is actually teaching. Mind blowing!
March 25, 2010 at 3:46 pm
It’s crazy to me that guys like Brian McLaren seem to care most about making people feel good about themselves when the gospel of Jesus Christ is the only thing that gives true joy. Knowing that you are covered in the blood is what makes you feel good about yourself and that joy is everlasting.
March 25, 2010 at 3:40 pm
One thing I think to understand is that churches have failed in youth ministry. They have gotten people temporarily excited but not really taken the time to go in depth and have real discipleship happen. Many students don’t come out of youth ministry with any concept of what it means to think Christianly in the world. One often designs church and worship music for those who are 9th grade intellectually. When they grow up intellectually and leave the church, we shouldn’t be shocked.
Good post Greg.
March 25, 2010 at 4:04 pm
Connie is there a big Emergent influence where you guys are?
Thanks Brady! I think there is a transcendence/immanence issue when speaking of how we teach our youth. I’m thinking specifically of Collin Hansen’s book where he discusses this. We often don’t teach our students about the transcendence of God, and we only share that God helps us with our sin, moves us, is our friend, etc.
March 25, 2010 at 6:13 pm
Well Rob Bell is in Grand Rapids and there are a good amount of people (even a couple at my church) who are very influenced by him, through his books and also by attending his church. It bothers me because I’ve seen him ignore biblical truths concerning homosexuality and other things. I just hate to see people believing the things he says over scripture. I love this article you wrote and I love what Meghan Moughler said on your wall about the subject. I totally agree :)
March 25, 2010 at 7:36 pm
Thanks so much!
July 2, 2010 at 3:49 pm
I bought velvet elvis and started reading it, then i found out what Rob Bell is about