Few events in modern history fascinate us more than Nazi Germany during the 1930’s and 40’s. How could a historically Christian nation come under the spell of one of the most murderous, wicked tyrants to walk the earth? In the aftermath of World War II, the world stared aghast in unbelief at the atrocities committed by the Nazis: concentration camps, death squads, medical experiments on humans etc. After six years of war six million Jews had been murdered as well as tens of millions of civilians and soldiers on all sides.
The question that haunted and continues to haunt the world was where were the Christians in all this? In a country that birthed the Reformation, that sent the first protestant missionaries out of Europe (the Moravian Brethren), that was known to be civil, cultured and advanced came the most debased, villainous regime in recorded history. We all search and hope for some glimmer of light, a ray of hope, a dissenting voice among the satanic chorus.
The man is Dietrich Bonhoeffer. In this young Lutheran pastor we see who each one of us would hope to be: a sincere, courageous, active, devout pillar of truth amidst a million lies.
Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet, Spy by Eric Metaxas is worthy read. I promise. With no shortage of required readings and impending term papers, you’d think I’d wait a month until winter break. Only one problem: I started reading it…..and couldn’t put it down.
The best plot summary is summed-up in a sentence by Bonhoeffer himself: “Silence in the face of evil is itself evil: God will not hold us guiltless. Not to speak is to speak. Not to act is to act.”
Metaxas describes Bonhoeffer’s aristocratic upbringing, the impactful death of his 18 year old brother Walther in World War I and his desire to become a Theologian at a young age. A brilliant intellectual, he earned a doctorate of Theology at age 21. Bonhoeffer traveled extensively during his short life. He was cultured and erudite –every bit the German gentleman. And he was a devout Christian.
Bonhoeffer’s uncanny foresight into cultural injustice and Theological error is strikingly prophetic. In his trip to America in 1933 he attended Union seminary in New York. He was appalled at the Theological liberalism of the day. He heard the perennial liberal preacher Henry Emerson Fosdick and was alarmed that Christ was not preached. He was most moved by the piety and sincerity of the African America churches in the U.S but was saddened by the prevailing racism of the day.
Bonhoeffer saw the evils of National Socialism earlier than anyone in Germany. He was outspoken and rallied against Hitler publicly before he was silenced. He worked in every way he could to preserve the integrity of the gospel and genuine Christianity. When Hitler drove the nation into a world war, Bonhoeffer was proud to be a German but conceded that the only in defeat could his country be saved. Metaxas highlights the struggles of a man who loved his country and understood the complexities of serving one’s nation and obeying God-ordained authority. He trained pastors at Finkenwalde seminary in the 30’s and never told his students what they should do if called into military service. It was a matter between them and God. Of the 150 seminarians who attended during those years, 80 of them were killed in the second war.
The inner tension between fighting for your country in an unjust war and obeying higher authority was empathetically brought to light. There were good, devout Christian men serving in the German armed forces. During Bonhoeffer’s courtship with Maria Von Wedemeyer, her father and brother were killed during Stalingrad within a few weeks of each other. Bonheoffer confirmed Maria’s brother, Max just years earlier. It was heart wrenching to read.
Metaxas sheds light on the distinction between Christians serving in the army and the wicked, anti-Christian SS branch of the military. The SS and their leaders were animate in their detestation of Christianity. They were responsible for nearly all the atrocities done in the war. Many in Germany were not part of the SS nor were they aware, especially at the beginning of what they were doing. Metaxas rightfully vilifies the SS leaders who were the authors of the “Final Solution” (extermination of Jews in Europe) For instance, he says this about the death of Reinhard Heydrich:
On the positive side of things, Heydrich was dead. At the end of May, the albino stoat had been ambushed by Czech resistance fighters while he was riding in his open-top Merceded. Eight days later, the architect of the Final Solution fell into the hands of the God of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob.[1]
On the romantic note, Metaxas gives us a fascinating look into the relationship between the 18 year-old Wedemeyer and a man 18 years her senior. The letters of correspondence between the two are moving and memorable. Bonhoeffer had earlier resigned to a life of singleness for the sake of ministry –but this changed with the beautiful lady Wedemeyer. Shortly after their engagement in 1943, Bonhoeffer was imprisoned. This love story is tragic as Bonhoeffer was executed before they could wed. In his letters, he would express his love and devotion while hinting at his death with phrases such as, “can you go on without me?”
The crux of Bonhoeffer’s life was his belief that to act or not act in opposing Hitler by any and all means was the difference between obeying God in righteousness and staining one’s hands with blood of the innocent. Bonhoeffer, who considered himself a pacifist decided that joining the Abwehr (intelligence gathering agency) in order to plot against Hitler in an eventual assassination attempt was what God asked him to do. Most in Germany opposed to such action on grounds of violating their conscience.
Bonhoeffer knew that to live in fear of incurring “guilt” was itself sinful. God wanted his beloved children to operate out of freedom and joy to do what was right and good, not out of fear of making a mistake. To live in fear and guilt was to be “religious” in the pejorative sense that Bonhoeffer so often talked and preached about. He knew that to act freely could mean inadvertently doing wrong and incurring guilt. In fact, he felt that living this way meant that it was impossible to avoid incurring guilt, but if one wished to live responsibly and fully, one would be willing to do so.[2]
The bold, daring, righteous life Bonhoeffer lived led him to do what most wouldn’t do. He also conceded that everyone in the nation would suffer for the evils of the regime –not just those immediately involved.
Bonhoeffer’s life is so inspiring because, if we are all honest with ourselves, wonder if we would be like him or the millions of Christians who stood idly because of fear or simply to salve our consciences. May this man, fully-devoted to God and submissive to his will, be an inspiration we seek to emulate in our own generation.
[1] Eric, Metaxas, Bonhoeffer: Pastor, Martyr, Prophet , Spy (Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson, 2010), 404.
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.
December 13, 2011
0 Comments